STRAIGHT TALK
Why does my sister ask her girlfriend for help with medical decisions, instead of me?
My lesbian sister is fighting breast cancer and trying to decide what kind of treatments are right for her. I feel very cut off from this process because she takes her longtime girlfriend’s advice and opinions more seriously than mine. I’m her older brother and used to being leaned on. Don’t I have the right to ask my sister to listen to me instead?
It sounds like you’re feeling left out at an important time in your sister’s life. But if your sister has been with her girlfriend for a long time, she may consider her a full-on partner or spouse, so it’s probably a good idea if you try and think of her that way as well.
Even our federal government is beginning to catch up in the area of respecting LGBT partnerships on medical matters: In April, President Obama signed an executive order requiring hospitals to give gay partners hospital visitation rights, a pretty big step forward for a federal government that is nonetheless still behind on recognizing many other aspects of gay relationships.
Among the things you can do to help your sister is making an effort to support her relationship and their decisions, especially if they’re getting flack from other family members. I also suggest doing your best to focus on your sister’s immediate problem—her health condition—instead of on the details of her girlfriend’s influence.
Of course, if you feel strongly that the girlfriend is influencing your sister to make bad decisions, you’re completely within your rights to bring that up privately with your sister. As her sibling, watching her back is pretty much your job after all.
Even our federal government is beginning to catch up in the area of respecting LGBT partnerships on medical matters: In April, President Obama signed an executive order requiring hospitals to give gay partners hospital visitation rights, a pretty big step forward for a federal government that is nonetheless still behind on recognizing many other aspects of gay relationships.
Among the things you can do to help your sister is making an effort to support her relationship and their decisions, especially if they’re getting flack from other family members. I also suggest doing your best to focus on your sister’s immediate problem—her health condition—instead of on the details of her girlfriend’s influence.
Of course, if you feel strongly that the girlfriend is influencing your sister to make bad decisions, you’re completely within your rights to bring that up privately with your sister. As her sibling, watching her back is pretty much your job after all.
More of STRAIGHT TALK:
Being inclusive of the kids of gay parents in the classroom
Do gay people need their own vacation spots?
Why does my sister ask her girlfriend for help with medical decisions, instead of me?
How to address mail to lesbian and gay couples?
Don’t kids who have two dads feel left out of Mother’s Day?
Is it ever okay for straight people to use slang like queer, dyke or queen?
Are seating arrangements different for same-sex couples?
How do I introduce my gay friends?
My husband’s gay—what should I say?
Do gay people need their own vacation spots?
Why does my sister ask her girlfriend for help with medical decisions, instead of me?
How to address mail to lesbian and gay couples?
Don’t kids who have two dads feel left out of Mother’s Day?
Is it ever okay for straight people to use slang like queer, dyke or queen?
Are seating arrangements different for same-sex couples?
How do I introduce my gay friends?
My husband’s gay—what should I say?
Sign up for “Queeries,” our free e-mail newsletter about coming out, the rules of courtship, planning a same-sex commitment ceremony, bringing baby on board, confronting homophobia, saying good-bye to a dying friend, and much more.
E-MAIL ADDRESS
RECENT POSTS
RECENT QUEERIES
ASK STEVEN
Got a gay manners question? Ask the expert right here, right now.
E-MAIL YOUR QUESTION
E-MAIL YOUR QUESTION
Updated 08.31.2010
Q: Here’s the deal: While I was on vacation this summer, I met this guy on the beach. That night, we bumped into each other at…
Updated 09.02.2010
Q: Too chicken to tell my ex about my STD
I need to tell my ex that I contracted a venereal disease and that I may have passed it on to her, but I can’t bear the idea of talking to her. Is it rude to just…
Q: Too chicken to tell my ex about my STD
I need to tell my ex that I contracted a venereal disease and that I may have passed it on to her, but I can’t bear the idea of talking to her. Is it rude to just…
CONTACT | TERMS OF SERVICE | PRIVACY POLICY | MEDIA ROOM | SITE CREDITS
FOLLOW STEVEN PETROW'S GAY & LESBIAN MANNERS ON
FACEBOOK 
TWITTER